• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Marathi Investor

Survival is the only way to get Rich

  • Home
  • Stocks Market Basics
  • Investing
    • Investing Books
      • Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits
      • the DHANDHO INVESTOR
      • Security Analysis
      • Stocks to Riches Book Summary
      • Intelligent Investor
      • One Up On Wall Street
      • the DHANDHO INVESTOR
  • Accounting
  • Mutual Fund
  • Bitcoin Investing
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Investing / Investing Books / Security Analysis / Security Analysis: Chapter 12

Security Analysis: Chapter 12

September 30, 2021 by Laxman Sonale Leave a Comment

Hello friends in today’s article, we see chapter 12 of the Security analysis book. In this chapter, we see a special factor in the Analysis of Railroad and Public-Utility companies. so let’s start with Railroad Bond analysis.

Previous Chapter

Railroad Bond Analysis:-Security Analysis: Chapter 12

Security Analysis: Chapter 12

so let’s, in this

The authors said, ” those are railroad companies they have maximum data. so those are individuals who have the competency to analyze data correctly.

The author also, says, ” if we have to do high-grade bond analysis, then why we invest in this bond, instead of a bond.

we can invest in stocks, with that much analysis, which means, there are no more benefits of analysis when we invest in the high-grade bond.

Just we have to keep remember is that those are income generating, they are more above the interest charges means good interest coverage ratios. (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

so another thing, is that those are stock value ratio is also high.

Then the author talks about the railroad industry general things like

those are light traffic, they go in the truck, and those are passenger traffic they go in their own car.

so only heavy traffic remains for Railroad, traffic like, Coal, iron steal, mineral transport.

so railroad success, depends on this thing also, that much increases then profit increases.

and another also quantitative part is an available book,  if you want to learn, more about the railroad, then buy the book from the following link

so let’s start with Public Utility company bond analysis

Public Utility Bond Analysis:-Security Analysis: Chapter 12

In public utility bond analysis have three problems, they are as follows

1 ) People think, the application of the term of the public utility to on industrial operations.

so this is not the right thing, for the right things, we have to define and understand the public utility definition.

Public utilities are those types of companies that are providing essential services under government regulation and the most important thing is on public utility is ‘ they are stable and have legal right to charge that much to be a profitable and good return on capital investment.

stability means,

They are relatively stable with other companies in the same industry.

then the author says,” Nowadays, pseudo Utility comes more like, selling ice, operating taxi cabs, owning cold storage plant. so people also called, then also public utility.

So this is the first problem,

so these are actually industrial operations but they mean people called them a public utility.

Nowadays their combination come( 1933)(author talk in 1933, don’t forget that)

like, Natural gas is combined with Ice Plant. (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

2) the second problem is that this one bond issue whatever their prospective they use the prior-deductions method to calculate interest coverage ratio.

we lastly talk about this method, is they are a useless method, we have to use total method.

This problem is that those are junior bond issues, they are more covered properly as compare to senior bond issues.

If you apply common sense, you see these are nonsense things.

3) the third problem is that companies do not include the depression charges, while considered or finding interest coverage ratio. if they may be understated depression or not include then.

If someone says, your depreciation is the only bookkeeping thing concept, then your money is not spent properly.

then it means, that if you listen then or agree with them, that means they make you fools or you become a fool by them.

Depression is important and you have to subtract them, because, your instruments use daily, and their value becomes less sometimes later they become obsolete.

So that instruments losing their power by using daily, for that we have to subtract depreciation and other problem is unstable in this problem, the author says,

minimum 10% of gross revenue and 4% of total profit value, that much have to subtract.

If you want to be more conservative, then you can take 12% of gross revenue as a minimum.

4) there is the fourth problem is that

those are Federal taxes are imposed after deduction interest.

How you can find, = EBIT/interest expenses

But most of the time, those are corporate people, in their reports, they deduct the tax first, and then show the earning, and then coverage ratio is found. (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

So you don’t give the tax paid first, so in this, you don’t worry about from where I am and add tax and earning the become minimum.

So this is a good thing, you have become more conservative and you take past then actual earning, so this is no problem.

because they don’t give any big difference by adding tax.

But if you analysis of a Holding company bond, then, you have to worry about some

So those are holding company they have to pay subsidiaries and their subsidiaries bond issues and preferred stocks payments.

So holding company, first have to pay their subsidiaries preferred stocks or bond issues, and after that holding companies bond issues charges.

so in this, we have to consider the tax.

Those are preferred dividends, you have to pay to subsidiaries and tax on them and after whatever earnings come, you can use it. (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

Then the author gives the Example, How a company fools the Investor.

How a company Fools the Investor:

The companies debenture Issues, they have price is about $3,000,000

and companies business is, this company operate 20 telephone companies and 4 ice companies.

Value of property = $12,500,000

After depreciation, this value is equal to $1650 per $1000 bond issues after deduction of prior obligations.

so following are the income account.

Gross earnings – $3,361,000

Net Before Depreciation – $969,000

Prior Deductions – $441,000

Balance for Debentures – $528,000

interest on Debentures – $195,000

Balance for Stocks – $ 333,000

the Balace is above 2.71 X(times)  interest on this issues.

so how they found this,

so Coverage ratio= Debentures balance / Interest of debentures

coverage ratio = $528,000 / $195,000

coverage ratio = 2.71X

the question arises

What is the problem with these ratios

so the first problem in this is as follows

1) Business combined means, the actual utility is mixed with industrial operations but they are ice plants. (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

and they don’t give the gross and net income of ice plants

we don’t know how much percentage from the ice plant and how much percent from the telephone company.

so they don’t give us

if we assume ice business give maximum percentage income, that’s why they try to hide this.

second problem

2) the second problem is Depreciation is not subtracted.

Those are other telephone companies whose 15% of gross revenue is the depreciation.

so,

If we take 15% of depreciation = 15% of $3,361,000  

depreciation = $ 500,000

If we take Net income after depreciation = $969,000 – $500,000

Net Income = $ 469,000

and then we take calculations as follows, we get the result

Balance for debentures = $ 469,000 – $441,000

Balnce for debentures = $ 28,000

and Interest on debentures = $ 195,000

so they are not equal to the debentures

this is the trick

so if we can not assume $500,000 depreciation, Because, those are ICE plants, their depreciation is very less.

so we can assume depreciation as $300,000 ( i.e. 9th 1/2 % of Gross revenue.)

third problem

3) Third Problem is that they used the prior- Deductions method.

In this we get the debentures safety

Debentures safety = $ 528,000 / $195,000 

Debenture safety= 2.71X

and If we see for the senior bond issue, we get as follows

Senior bond safety= $969,000 / $441,000

Means Senior Issue is less secured and Debenture issues is more secure(junior bond issues)

So this is not a logical thing, as compared to the seniority (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

If we make the right income account is as follows

Restating property:

Gross Earnings – $3,361,000

Net before Depreciation – $969,000

Depreciation – $ 300,000

Balance for Interest – $669,000

Total Interest Charges – $441,000 + $195,000

Total Interest charges – $636,000

Coverage Ratio – $669,000 / $636,000  

Coverage Ratio – 1.05X

 

so forth problem

4) So fourth problem is that,

they say, $1650 of property value behind each $1000 debentures

so given,

Property Value – $12.5 million

Total Debt – $ 10.5 Million

Senior debt – $7.5 Million

Debentures – $ 3 million

so how much actual coverage ratio, we get

let’s find it out

for that,

Calculations:

property Value / Total Debt = $ 12.5 M / $10.5 M = 1.19

( M denote here – Millions)

It means only, i.e. $1190 of property value behind $1000 of total Debt.

so what companies say, How they get see following calculations

where they misguided ( mistake) (Security Analysis: Chapter 12)

Property Value for Debentures = $ 12.5 M – $ 7.5 M

Property Value for debentures:- $ 5 M

Debentures = $ 3 M

Property / total Debt = $ 5 M / $ 3 M

so that why come $ 1650

so in this time, they used the prior deductions method ( that method secure junior) to fool investor

if we apply for senior, then they are $ 1400 of property value behind each $1000 of senior debt.

Means Senior is less safe if we see the only a number

so this type, Companies make fool to investor

Read More Books summaries as follows

1) The Intelligent Investor

2) One Up On Wall Street

3) Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits

4) Rich Dad Poor Dad

facebookShare on Facebook
TwitterTweet
FollowFollow us

Filed Under: Security Analysis

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search Post

Please follow & like us :)

Facebook
Facebook
fb-share-icon
YouTube
Instagram
Twitter
Visit Us
Follow Me
Tweet
Pinterest
Pinterest
fb-share-icon
LinkedIn
LinkedIn
Share
Telegram

Recent Posts

  • Blockchain Technology Investment
  • Is bitcoin the future of Money?
  • Is Bitcoin a Currency or an Investment?
  • How Bitcoin’s Prices Increases in Past?
  • What gives Bitcoin Value?

Recent Comments

  • Defensive Investor Qualities - The Marathi Investor on 15 points of outstanding company
  • The Intelligent Investor: Chapter 2 - The Marathi Investor on One Up On Wall Street: Chapter 5
  • Enterprising investor need qualities to success - The Marathi Investor on Investment Secret of Warren Buffett
  • Intelligent Investor: Chapter 9 - The Marathi Investor on Common Stocks & Uncommon Profits: Chapter 4
  • Intelligent Investor: Chapter 12 - The Marathi Investor on Common Stocks & Uncommon Profits: Chapter 4

Categories

  • Accounting (1)
  • Bitcoin Investing (9)
  • Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits (12)
  • Intelligent Investor (19)
  • Investing (10)
  • Investing Books (1)
  • Mutual Fund (1)
  • One Up On Wall Street (22)
  • Security Analysis (16)
  • Stocks Market Basics (1)
  • Stocks to Riches Book Summary (11)
  • the DHANDHO INVESTOR (13)
  • Uncategorized (1)

How to deal with Mr. Market

The Intelligent Investor Chapter 8:- Investor and Market Fluctuations

50,000 Frenchman can be wrong

One up on wall street Chapter 20

Best time to Buy and Sell Stocks

When to Buy and sell stocks

Common Stocks and Uncommon profits Book Summary

Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits book review

Footer

Financial Literacy

Stocks to Riches Chapter 13L- Financial Literacy to Become Rich

Loss Aversion & Sunk Cost Fallacy Bias

Stocks to Riches:- Chapter 5 Loss Aversion and Sunk Cost Fallacy Bias

Mutual Funds:- Good or Bad?

Stocks to riches Chapter 9:- Mutual fund good or bad

When to Buy Stock ( by Philip A. Fisher)

When to buy stocks

Sources of Information about Company

Annual Reports of the Company: security Analysis

Follow us

Get new posts by email

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in